I have (for the most part) not been commenting on people's posts about the situation wildfiring through SPN fandom at the moment. It is not because I don't care, but because I care too much. And because I am extremely uncomfortable with my comments being screencapped and used by people I do not know (or do not know if I know or not, because they are anon) for their own purposes.
Sometimes when we have strong feelings about something it makes us brilliant and articulate. Sometimes it makes us broken and dumb. I am feeling more the latter than the former, but I also feel like I cannot keep silent regarding something I feel so strongly about. The parts of this I cannot find words for have been discussed by some of those brilliant and articulate people. I hope very much that they won't mind if I send you in their direction and let what they have to say about victim-blaming, knee-jerk reactions, and cultures of violence speak for me.
brihana25's
post which is a sort of open letter without naming names.
kroki_refur's
post which is the one that made me feel like I could corral the frenzy of discomfort in my head and actually breathe again.
drvsilla's
post which speaks to how I can have genuine sympathy for everyone concerned and still feel violated and horrified by how this is playing out. (and I do not mean to put words in Dru's mouth wrt feeling violated and horrified. those are MY feelings. I'm sure she has her own.)
and
sparkymonster has a
post about rape culture and how that is contributing to the situation.
Thank you, ladies, and all the other people who found themselves able to talk about this issue in a calm and clear manner, in a way that I cannot.
What I
can talk about is Wincon.
I LOVE Wincon. I love the women who work so incredibly hard to make Wincon the amazing and wonderful place that it is. I love the fangirls who are crazy and diverse and wacky and wild and wonderful. I was at Baltimore in 2008, and I was at Denver in 2009, and I will be in Chicago in 2010 (I bought my ticket before the last con was even over).
There were problems in Baltimore. Not just the problems that have suddenly come up in an inappropriately public way* via the anon meme and the response to it, but problems with the hotel and getting food and some of the rooms. And
coiledsoul and
ethrosdemon did AMAZING and WONDERFUL things to make sure those problems were solved. Things that happened behind the scenes, that none of the con-goers had reason to know about, but that ensured that we got fed in Baltimore anyway and when we arrived in Denver there was food and drink and internet and awesomeness in the extreme. These women and all the women who helped them, who contributed time and energy and effort, did it because they love fandom and they want Wincon to be an amazing experience for people as much as possible. But they don't just care about breakfast tickets, and hotel liaison duties, and event planning. They care that people are having a good time. They
ask and if there is a problem or something that needs to change, they address it. Even when it's hard. Even when it's uncomfortable. Even when it's not popular.
They do it quietly, and straight up, and on behalf of people who feel like they can't do it themselves for whatever reason. They are amazing, and they are advocates, and I really do not have words for how much I admire them. It's unfortunate in the extreme that the anon discussion and the response to it is getting conflated with their appropriate, and behind-the-scenes (so far as they were concerned), actions.
I've been going back and forth for two days, and all the while writing this, as to whether I would post it public or not. As I said, I am extremely uncomfortable with the manner in which this situation is being "recorded for posterity". But I'm a hell of a lot more uncomfortable with a lot more than that, and I think my screencapping discomfort pales into insignificance in the face of that.
I may or may not be answering comments on this post. I may end up breaking my rule against answering some comments but not others. I apologize in advance for that, but as may be clear, I'm having trouble talking about this, and I am not willing to add to my own discomfort by engaging just to be polite.
please let me clarify: I do not believe that it is inappropriate to discuss issues of being made to feel uncomfortable or anything related to coercion etc. in public. I do not believe it is inappropriate to do so anonymously. I do not believe those things even a little bit. But I do think that there have been a lot of things said publicly that should have been kept private, and a lot of things said publicly without appropriate context, and that people are being hurt. Very, very hurt, as a result.