I like the first one the most, probably, but I voted for the second 'cause I feel like the first would be hard to get as a tattoo; I've yet to come across a tattoo artist who would do faded ink like that. But that's probably just my experience/the few places we have around my house. I love this idea, though. I have a couple of geeky tattoos, and one that represents fandom to me but it's from HP, since that was my first one--I like that this is fandom as a whole.